Health care’s ‘public option’ would cover little of population
A proposed government-run health insurance program, among the most divisive issues in the health care debate, would cover less than 1.5% of the population, new estimates show.
The latest version of the “public option,” included in the 10-year, $848 billion health care bill headed toward an initial Senate vote Saturday, would cover up to 4 million people, according to the Congressional Budget Office report released late Wednesday night.
The issue remains among those that have prevented Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid from securing the 60 votes he needs to pass the bill.
Paul Ginsburg, an economist with the Center for Studying Health System Change, questions the impact the public option proposals would have on families seeking health coverage.
“The type of public option we’re talking about today … is all about ideology and symbolism,” he said. “It’s not going to have any impact on our health system.”
SIDE-BY-SIDE: Comparing the House and Senate health bills
Reid, D-Nev., scheduled a weekend vote to determine whether the Senate will begin debate on its health care plan, which includes a public insurance program that individual states could choose not to offer residents.
The public plan was conceived as a separate insurance policy that would operate like Medicare, the government-run health program for seniors. President Obama has said a public option would “keep pressure on private insurers to keep their policies affordable.”
Under the House and Senate bills, the government option would be available only to people who shop for insurance on their own — meaning they don’t get coverage through work — or who work for small firms. The plan would be offered alongside private policies in online “exchanges” that would let people compare coverage and prices.
Like private insurers, the public plan’s funding would come from premiums, but Republicans and some Democrats, including Sen. Ben Nelson of Nebraska, say its non-profit status would give it an unfair advantage. “A government plan is eventually going to crowd out the private insurance companies’ plans,” said Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison, R-Texas.
The public plan included in the House bill would cover 6 million people, the Congressional Budget Office predicted. The analysis predicted that the public plan would attract less healthy patients and that its average premiums would be “somewhat higher” than private plans.
The Senate bill would let states opt out of the public plan. States that are home to one-third of the population would be likely to do so, the CBO predicts.
Jacob Hacker, a Yale University political scientist who first proposed the public option, said the plan would still drive down health care costs despite the changes. For one thing, he said, it would offer consumers another choice in rural parts of the country where only one or two insurers offer policies.
Insurance companies oppose the program. Karen Ignagni, head of the trade group America’s Health Insurance Plans, says the public plan would underpay doctors, forcing them to shift the cost to patients with private coverage.
Under pressure from fellow Democrats, Reid and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., reduced the plan’s power. Unlike Medicare, which decides how much to pay doctors for services, the public plan would negotiate with doctors as private insurers do.
About the Author
Quoting & Saving just got easier…EasyToInsureME Health Insurance Quotes… Quote all carriers in seconds
Nebraska Health Insurance
Iowa Health Insurance
American People Oppose Health Care Bill, But Democrats Move Forward Anyway
|
|
Sicko (Special Edition) $3.49 For many Americanslaughter isn’t the best medicine – it’s the only medicine.ProductInformationIn Sicko filmmaker Michael Moore returns with a hilariously scathingindictment of America’s failing health system. Combiningpowerful personal testimonies with shocking statistics Moore pulls thecurtain back on the greedy HMOs drug companies and congressmen whokeep us ill. Traveling to Canada E… |
|
|
Chappelle’s Show – Season 2 $11.48 Dave Chappelle’s shrewd parodies, stinging satires, and boldly imaginative fantasias simply pour from the second season of his Comedy Central show, in every respect as funny as his well-received debut year. The structure is the same: a relaxed Chappelle introduces each sketch to an enthusiastic, studio audience (some of these introductions amount to stand-up routines), and then the madness begins…. |
|
|
The Doctor $6.90 DOCTOR – DVD Movie… |
|
|
Chia Obama Handmade Decorative Planter $28.57 contains: handmade pottery planter; Chia seed packet for 3 plantings; convenient plastic drip tray; planting and care instruction sheet…. |
|
|
Beautiful Slim Body Original NHATHUOCHOADA- 36 Soft Gel ~ Made in USA $11.99 Beautiful Slim Body Soft Gel capsules contain multiple plants with natural slimming effect, such as xian xian cao, jobs tears, artemisia dracunculus, psyllium husk, bamboo shoot, and lotus leaf. These pills work by suppressing the gastro-intestinal tract enzyme activeness, decreasing fat absorption, and increasing body energy consumption and decomposing fat. It also works to activate cell in vivo,… |
|
|
Ivory Caps – Maximum Potency 1500 mg Glutathione Skin Whitening Pills Complex **SALE REG. $49.99 – NOW $29.99 – FREE SHIPPING $29.99 In 2004 the makers of Ivory Caps® had embarked on a business plan to develop the company’s most powerful skin lightening product. Not only was this formula meant to be effective, but also safe for normal use. Though the idea was simple enough, the research and development to create such a product was surprisingly extensive. Every possible factor was considered in creating this revolutionary propr… |
|
|
The Baby Book: Everything You Need to Know About Your Baby from Birth to Age Two (Revised and Updated Edition) $9.99 In their excellent (and hefty) resource guide, The Baby Book, attachment parenting specialists William Sears and Martha Sears have provided new parents with their approach to every aspect of baby care basics, from newborns to toddlers. Attachment parenting is a gentle, reasonable approach to parenting that stresses bonding with your baby, responding to her cues, breastfeeding, “wearing” your… |
|
|
Motivational Interviewing, Second Edition: Preparing People for Change $42.78 This bestselling work has introduced hundreds of thousands of professionals and students to motivational interviewing (MI), a proven approach to helping people overcome ambivalence that gets in the way of change. William R. Miller and Stephen Rollnick explain current thinking on the process of behavior change, present the principles of MI, and provide detailed guidelines for putting it into practi… |
|
|
Motivational Interviewing in Health Care: Helping Patients Change Behavior (Applications of Motivational Interviewin) $21.62 Much of health care today involves helping patients manage conditions whose outcomes can be greatly influenced by lifestyle or behavior change. Written specifically for health care professionals, this concise book presents powerful tools to enhance communication with patients and guide them in making choices to improve their health, from weight loss, exercise, and smoking cessation, to medication… |
|
|
||
Manna Pro Animal Health Aids Nurseall 3.5# |
Mada Equipment Company Gauge Protective Covers - Model 92016 - Each |
||
| click for price Sears.com | click for price Sears.com | ||
|
|
